Results of the RISM User Study, Part IV: Your Comments - Libraries, Coverage, and Completeness
Friday, August 14, 2015
The week concludes with another close look at the comments you made in the recent RISM survey.
“I just wish some very important institutions like A-Wgm [Vienna, Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde] were also listed.” - Respondent 135
The core of this question came up often, variously naming specific institutions such as the French National Library (F-Pn) and the Austrian National Library (A-Wn), more Italian libraries or Portuguese collections in general, and then wishes for private collections or certain composers to be included.
So you are looking for musical sources? You go to RISM first and you’re surprised that there are only about 2,000 manuscripts from the Austrian National Library?
How can such a big library have so few entries in RISM? Part of the reason is that since larger state or national libraries frequently had the means to make their holdings known through printed or online catalogs, it was always a particular concern for RISM to ensure that musical sources from smaller collections were documented.
So did you know that the Archives d’Arenberg in Enghien, Belgium (B-Earenberg) holds numerous opera arias by André-Ernest-Modeste Grétry, Johann Paul Aegidus Martini, and Pietro Torri? Or did you ever wonder how Emanuele d’Astorga’s secular cantatas ended up in the Abbaye de Maredsous (B-MAR; RISM ID no. 703000738)?
And who would have thought that the reputation of Joseph Haydn’s Nelson Mass reached all the way to Mexico in the second half of the eighteenth century? A copy of the mass in D minor (Hob. XXII:11) is held today by the Archivo Musical de la Parroquia in Oaxaca, Mexico (MEX-SCHamp Sa-Ms-01-39, RISM ID no. 120000416). This source was not known when the work appeared in the collected works of Haydn (Reihe XXIII, Band 3), which was published back in 1965.
It is true that several major institutions are disproportionately represented in RISM, and we are working with them to transfer their data to our catalog. Today it is easier than ever to get data from external catalogs. See our Data Services page for more details.
To summarize this past week, the comments that we have discussed are only a small portion of the numerous questions and comments we received from the survey. Further results will be presented at the AIBM conference in Stuttgart next month. Additional questions will be answered on our website and we hope to incorporate your suggestions into the next versions of the online catalog. The complete results will be published at the end of this year.
Photo credit: Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, Prunksaal. Manfred Morgner, Wikimedia CommonsShare Tweet Email